Pheroquirk
![Offline Offline](images/midnight/buddy_offline.gif)
Contributes Regularly
![](./images/avatars/noavatar.gif)
Joined: Oct 2010
Sex: Male
Posts: 258
Reputation: 2952
Rep Post
Thanks Given: 1109
Thanks received:
358 thanks in 153 posts
|
the importance of magic in social structures
04-05-2012 2:47 PM
Quote:n our modern way of thought, few things can be more contemptible than superstition. Words like ‘magic’ and ‘witchcraft’ are taken to be synonymous with everything dark and barbaric.
Yet every pre-industrial society and plenty of post-industrial societies include magic as a regular part of daily life.
Whether magic is ‘true’ or not is of little relevance. We can divine that societies with belief in magic had a competitive advantage over those that did not.
If we really look at what magic is, we find that its function is pretty consistent and straightforward. It’s a means of influencing the human subconscious.
Let’s look at a typical shamanic strategy: Tell the family that the sick person is inhabited by a demon and that it can only be driven away if the family members are totally devoted in their hearts to recovery.
Is there really a demon causing the disease? Who cares? The shaman has inspired a sense of urgency in the family and caused them to really take the situation seriously. Attitude influences action and the shaman has gotten their attitude in the right place so that the right actions follow.
It’s a pretty straightforward chain of causation that almost unanimously escapes ‘rational’ modern thinkers.
In fact the relationship between the shaman and his patient is pretty similar that between worker and boss. Begin with incentives(worker gets fired if they screw up), then watch for results(worker knows on a visceral level they can’t screw up).
Magic has already been discovered by science.
The proof is a cure that often proves the equal of the best technology has to offer. Medical science calls it a ‘placebo’ a totally useless pill that actually works if you just add belief.
Yet Enlightenment thought in its worship of the Absolute Explicit still tries to tell us the placebo doesn’t work. People just think it works. Therefore if people are cured by the placebo effect they are irrational and deluded. They’ve been tricked.
Some shamans might agree with scientists that they ‘trick’ people but the connotations and implications of this word would be understood very differently.
To the ‘rational’ thinker the effects of a placebo treatment actually do not exist because the treatment itself was not explicit or measurable. To them the shaman is a primitive lout and a charlatan.
If any word hits a nerve with Enlightenment thinkers, it is ‘witchcraft.’
|
|
04-05-2012 2:47 PM |
|
Thanks given by |
dbot, AlternativeGirl, eyeofra, idontknow
|
Share This Thread
Site Developed and maintained by Powered By - Theme inspired by